On this page
- What are award criteria?
- What does MEAT mean?
- How does price-quality scoring work?
- How is price scored?
- How is quality scored?
- Worked example: a small IT firm
- Formula criteria versus judgement criteria
- What is life-cycle costing?
- What happens with an abnormally low tender?
- How to win more points
- Common mistakes with award criteria
- Frequently asked questions
You can meet every requirement, submit on time and still lose by a few points. Understanding how a buyer scores offers is the single most useful thing you can learn before writing a bid. This guide explains the award criteria used in EU public tenders, what "MEAT" really means, and how small and mid-sized companies can turn the scoring rules to their advantage.
What are award criteria?#
Award criteria are the published rules the buyer uses to rank the offers that passed the earlier checks. They are set before the procedure starts, published in the notice or the tender documents with their weights, and cannot be changed while bids are being evaluated.
Every bid goes through roughly four gates:
Exclusion: is the company barred from bidding (for example for unpaid taxes or a fraud conviction)?
Selection: does it have the minimum capacity, such as turnover, insurance and references? This is pass or fail.
Compliance: does the offer meet every mandatory requirement and use the buyer's forms?
Award: which compliant offer is the best according to the award criteria?
Only the last gate is a competition. The first three are thresholds you either clear or don't. If you want to brush up on those, read the qualification guide.
What does MEAT mean?#
MEAT is short for the most economically advantageous tender. Article 67 of Directive 2014/24/EU says contracts are awarded to the MEAT, identified on the basis of price or cost. In practice that covers three models:
Best price-quality ratio (BPQR): price plus qualitative criteria such as methodology, staff, delivery time or environmental performance. This is the most common model for services.
Lowest cost: a cost-effectiveness approach, for example life-cycle costing (Article 68) that adds energy use, maintenance and disposal to the purchase price.
Lowest price: the cheapest compliant offer wins. The directive allows it, but member states can restrict it, and many buyers prefer quality criteria for anything beyond simple supplies.
The criteria must be linked to the subject of the contract, must not give the buyer unrestricted freedom of choice, and must allow offers to be compared objectively. The weighting (or at least the order of importance) is published in advance.
How does price-quality scoring work?#
A typical services tender might say: price 40 points, quality 60 points, with quality split into sub-criteria. Each part is scored differently.
How is price scored?#
Price is almost always scored with a formula stated in the documents. Two common types:
Proportional: the lowest price gets full marks and others get
lowest price ÷ your price × max points.Linear or difference-based: points fall by a fixed amount for every percentage above the lowest price, or relative to the budget.
The formula matters. With a proportional formula, being 10 % more expensive than the cheapest bidder costs you about 10 % of the price points. With some linear formulas the same gap can cost much more. Run the formula on a few scenarios before you set your price.
How is quality scored?#
Quality is usually scored by an evaluation committee using a published scale, for example:
| Score | Meaning |
|---|---|
| 0 | Not addressed or unacceptable |
| 1 | Weak: generic, little evidence |
| 3 | Adequate: meets the requirement |
| 5 | Excellent: specific, evidenced, adds value |
Sub-criteria might be "methodology (25)", "team and organisation (20)", "quality assurance (10)" and "sustainability (5)". Some buyers add a minimum quality score: offers below it are eliminated whatever their price.
Worked example: a small IT firm#
A municipality tenders a support contract. Weights: price 40, quality 60. Three bids:
| Bidder | Price | Price points (proportional) | Quality points | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A (large integrator) | €180,000 | 33.3 | 38 | 71.3 |
| B (small IT firm) | €200,000 | 30.0 | 51 | 81.0 |
| C (low-cost provider) | €150,000 | 40.0 | 22 | 62.0 |
The small firm wins despite being the most expensive. Being €20,000 dearer than A cost it only 3.3 price points, while its concrete methodology earned 13 more quality points. That is the core lesson of MEAT: know the exchange rate between quality points and price.
Formula criteria versus judgement criteria#
Many countries distinguish criteria scored automatically by formula (price, delivery days, warranty years, a certified share of recycled material) from criteria scored by expert judgement (methodology, project plan).
In Spain and Italy this distinction has consequences: judgement-based content goes in one envelope and price plus formula-scored figures in another, and the judgement envelope is opened and scored first. Putting a price or a formula figure in the wrong envelope can get your bid excluded.
What is life-cycle costing?#
Under Article 68 a buyer may compare offers on the total cost of ownership: acquisition, use (energy, consumables), maintenance and end-of-life costs, and sometimes the cost of environmental externalities such as emissions. The method and the data you must provide are set out in the documents.
For a construction SME bidding to install heating systems, this can be an opportunity: a more efficient system with a higher purchase price can win if the buyer counts ten years of energy costs.
What happens with an abnormally low tender?#
If your price looks too low, the buyer must ask you to explain it before rejecting it (Article 69). Explanations can cover efficient methods, favourable conditions, original solutions or compliance with labour and environmental rules. The buyer must reject the offer if the low price comes from breaching environmental, social or labour law obligations.
Prepare a short cost breakdown for any aggressive price, because the deadline to answer is usually short.
How to win more points#
- 1
Map every criterion and sub-criterion
into a scoring table: weight, scoring method (formula or judgement), page limit and what "excellent" means.
- 2
Mirror the structure
one section per criterion, in the same order and with the same headings as the documents. Evaluators score what they can find.
- 3
Be specific and verifiable
named roles, response times, tools, examples from comparable contracts. Generic text scores "adequate" at best.
- 4
Answer the question asked
, not the one you wish was asked. Re-read the criterion wording before finalising each section.
- 5
Model your price
against the formula and against likely competitor prices.
- 6
Ask clarification questions
if the scoring method is unclear, before the question deadline.
- Legal basis
- Article 67 (award criteria), 68 (life-cycle costing), 69 (abnormally low tenders) of Directive 2014/24/EU
- Most common model
- best price-quality ratio
- Published in advance
- criteria and their weights or order of importance
- Price scoring
- always by formula stated in the documents
- Debriefing
- ask for your scores after the award
Common mistakes with award criteria#
Writing one long company presentation instead of answering each criterion separately.
Ignoring the page limit: extra pages may simply not be read.
Offering commitments you cannot deliver: they become contract terms.
Pricing without running the formula.
Not asking for a debriefing after losing, which is the cheapest way to learn how evaluators read your bid.
To put this into practice, continue with the guide on writing the bid itself, and see what happens after the deadline.
Frequently asked questions
What does MEAT mean in public procurement?
MEAT stands for the most economically advantageous tender. Under Article 67 of Directive 2014/24/EU it is identified on the basis of price or cost, and it can be the best price-quality ratio, the lowest cost (for example life-cycle cost) or, where allowed, the lowest price.
Can a public tender be awarded on price alone?
Yes, the EU directive allows it, but member states may restrict or forbid price-only award for certain buyers or types of contract. The tender documents always state the criteria and weights that apply.
What is an abnormally low tender?
A tender whose price or cost looks too low for the work. Under Article 69 the buyer must ask you to explain it before it can reject it, and must reject it if the low price comes from breaking environmental, social or labour law.
Are selection criteria and award criteria the same thing?
No. Selection criteria check whether your company is able to do the job (pass or fail). Award criteria compare the offers themselves and decide who wins.
Put it into practice
Search open tenders across Europe and save your searches to get new ones by email.